Comparing Shingles Versus Metal Roof Materials

As roofing materials continue to evolve, consumers are looking at many options when a repair or replacement situation arises. Metal and shingles are often the contenders for a final project, but both materials are extremely different from one another. A Monmouth County roofing professional can go over household options, but shingles usually win out over metal for most applications.

If any damage occurs to a metal roof, such as a hurricane or tornado, replacement is difficult. Metal materials are in large sections with complex fasteners. It may be necessary to remove most or all of the roof for just a basic repair. Shingles, in contrast, provide simple repair scenarios. One or several shingles are easily detached with quick nail-removal tools. Brand new shingles fit right into the space, making the repair fast and easy on almost any roof.

The roof is meant to protect the interior from damage, especially from hail or heavy rain. Muted sounds should also be a feature of the rooftop material to keep the home comfortable during hours of harsh weather. Shingles buffer sounds emanating into the interior, but metal actually increases them. Sitting indoors during a rainstorm may sound like a drumbeat until the weather abates. Although roofers try to insulate metal roofs to alleviate this occurrence, shingles still prove to be stronger against frustrating sounds.

If homeowners are looking for an affordable roofing material, metal is not part of the list. Expect to double a standard shingle roofing quote to substitute metal. Along with the material being more expensive, labor rates increase because of the complex fastening system. Because cost is a major consideration with roof repair and replacements, shingles are usually chosen as a strong solution.

Homeowners are familiar with those frustrating car door dings and dents from everyday driving, and metal roofing is no exception to this same damage. Hail and other hard objects striking the roof will mark its finish. It may even succumb to warping from hot summer days and frigid winter nights. Shingles don’t have the same surface that suffers from dents and warping, however. These materials have flexibility and strength through the years with only cracks, tears or weathering to worry about on the owner’s part.

Housing trends tend to lean on the newest introduced material, but tried-and-true products still hold the quality consumers want for their homes. When it comes to the roof, homeowners want the job done correctly the first time with the perfect materials. Standard shingles are strong materials even in today’s changing roofing world. Have a question regarding roof repairs or new roofs? Ask the roofers from Fortified Roofing of Monmouth County NJ.

Common roofers term explained by Fortified Roofing of Monmouth County NJ:


Permanent wavy appearance metal displays when under extreme stresses. Improper installation and extreme weather combine to force a flat metal roofing section into a bowed shape. Fasteners often snap and moisture can infiltrate the decking below in extreme cases.

Monmouth County NJ roofers at Fortified Roofing answers a question:

Which roofing material is a faster installation than others?

Although metal appears to have a faster installation time, shingles are actually quicker than most other materials. Nails, a nail gun and expert experience are all that’s necessary for shingle installations. Metal roofs attach in sections with specialized fasteners. These attachment points take longer to secure than just shingle connections on the average rooftop.

FREE Quick Estimate Request
Contact GAF Master Elite Roofer: Fortified Roofing

    Rated 4.7 out of 5 stars based on 8 customer reviews.

    Oh My! People say such nice things!